The Permatang Pauh by-election is progressing much more violently as I expected it would be. Though the Pakatan Rakyat leaders have been saying this could be the work of other groups out to sabotage the party, I think they should really check out their own members first.
Early this month, some of their supporters or members assaulted a female photographer from Guang Ming Daily and the top leadership, including Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah, had to publicly apologise to the photographer.
Then on nomination day, it is even worse. Two photographers were attacked and one of them even lost his camera to the hooligans who attacked him.
(Clockwise from top, left) A group surrounds several Barisan Nasional workers in a pick-up truck. Mohamad Sairien Mohamad Nafiz (in helmet) jumps on the vehicle to photograph the mob. He is then attacked and pulled to the ground where he is repeatedly kicked; before finally being rescued. - NST
Mohamad Sairien, 26, who suffered bodily injuries, also lost his RM15,000 Canon digital camera, while Berbar of the Kuala Lumpur-based HBL Press News Agency sustained head and leg injuries.
They were leaving the Tuanku Bainun Teacher Training College in Mengkuang after nominations had closed, when they were set upon at 1.30pm.
- New Straits Times
Now, a lot of bystanders will probably think it has nothing to do with PKR or Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s fight to win the Permatang Pauh seat. Well, I think it has. I think the top leadership are too blind to realise that they have all sorts of hooligans within their party while they continue to blame others for what their own party members are doing.
It is obvious that it is not the first time this type of incident has happened. There are many PKR members who are more violently inclined. They’ve been known to create a huge ruckus and generally be a real nuisance.
They’ve been known to curse and yell at the photographers and also the BN supporters, which incidentally lead to fights. The only problem is, all this was not usually highlighted in the media. Mainly because it went un-noticed due to the huge crowds that usually surge around Anwar wherever he goes. I have to hear about this from the grapevine
Some of these so-called ’security guards’ hired by PKR to keep the ruffians under control are even worse. They’ve been known to act all high and mighty, as if they have been bestowed the greatest power ever, and have no qualms using force to get people to feel ‘their power’.
In fact, I heard that they even told off our Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng’s bodyguard and warned him not to stand too near to Anwar. At that time, Guan Eng was seated next to Anwar on the stage during the rally early this month (the same time as the incident with the female photographer).
And that’s not the worse part. The worse part is that PKR leaders, especially the PKR state secretary Abdul Malik Abul Kassim have no freaking idea that this is going on. He, just like the rest of the PKR leaders, seemed to think that it is the work of ‘others’.
Even Anwar seemed to think it has nothing to do with the party at all.
Speaking to reporters in Penang today, PKR de facto leader Anwar Ibrahim said one should not jump to the conclusion that the perpetrators are party members.
“The mainstream media, (such as state-owned) RTM, will immediately apportion the blame to us. I say, let us investigate and punish those perpetrators, irrespective they are from Pakatan Rakyat or Barisan Nasional,” he said when asked to comment on the incident.
- Malaysiakini
They have not even identified the man who was caught on photograph choking a female photographer when grassroot members are so certain that he is a member of one of the PKR branches on the island. Till today, the man is still roaming free and I won’t be surprised that he’s probably still going to any ceramahs that Anwar has and continue to create more ruckus.

Hooligans within PKR assaulting a female photographer - The Sun
But of course, Anwar said he is not a party member but what about the six others who were also involved in the ruckus? They later surrounded the female photographer and would have beaten her up if not for intervention from another photographer from The Sun.
Referring to a similar incident earlier this month where a female photographer was assaulted by alleged PKR members, Anwar said an investigation later found the perpetrators were not linked to the party. (See photo by TheSun)
- Malaysiakini
Anwar should seriously look at his grassroots so that they do not, in their violent zealousness, throw a spanner into his battle to win the seat. We all know what he’s aiming for the moment he win that seat.
These hooligans may just be mere members (or ‘not members’ as he claimed) but it is enough. The damage is done.
Do we really want hooligans like this to be part of the governing party? It is time that Anwar and Abdul Malik and whoever is in charge to weed out all these ruffians. A few bad hats may not make a party but they still do give the party a ‘wonderful’ reputation and it sure won’t help in Anwar’s campaign.
After all, they don’t want to be known as Parti Keganasan Rakyat, do they?

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!